Independent editorial review · Updated April 2026 · Tested in real office environments
Editor's note

After six weeks of testing, we found one platform is the stronger all-round choice for most offices — and one is better in a narrow, specific case. Full reasoning below.

Comparison Review · Room Booking Software

Joan or Skedda — which room booking system actually fits your office?

We spent six weeks testing both platforms across real office environments — hardware, setup, visitor flow, calendar sync, analytics and pricing. Here's what we found, and how to decide.

By the OfficeTechReview editorial team · Last updated April 2026 · 8 min read

We tested both platforms independently over 6 weeks across real office environments. Neither vendor paid for or influenced this review.

6 weeks·40+ scenarios·300+ reviews
The Verdict

Joan has the broader advantage. Skedda wins one narrow use case.

After six weeks of testing across multiple office environments, Joan is the stronger all-round solution for most offices — it combines purpose-built ePaper hardware with a mature software platform covering room booking, desk booking, visitor management and analytics in a single system. Skedda is genuinely excellent at one thing: complex, rule-based booking logic. If your office has intricate scheduling rules and doesn't need hardware or visitor management, Skedda is a legitimate — and in some cases better — choice.

One caveat worth flagging: Joan requires a hardware investment upfront. For offices with tight budgets or fewer than 5 rooms, that changes the value calculation and Skedda's software-only model may make more sense.

Recommended for most offices
Joan logoJoan
4.9/5 editorial score

An all-in-one platform that covers the workflow most offices actually run — from the hallway display to the visitor sign-in.

  • Purpose-built ePaper hardware included
  • Visitor management built in
  • Advanced analytics & reporting
  • 15-minute setup per room
Best for

Offices from ~20 to 2,000+ employees that want one system for rooms, desks and visitors.

Trade-off

Hardware is an upfront cost. Small offices should factor this into the comparison.

Read more about Joan →

Free trial · No credit card required

Recommended for rule-heavy use cases
Skedda logoSkedda
4.3/5 editorial score

A specialist in one thing: flexible, rule-based booking. If your scheduling is complex and you don't need hardware or visitor management, this is a genuinely strong pick.

  • Best-in-class booking rules engine
  • Software-only — no hardware to buy
  • Purpose-built for shared / co-working spaces
Best for

Co-working spaces, universities and shared facilities with complex booking logic.

Trade-off

No hardware, no visitor management, no free tier since 2025.

Software-only platform · Rule-engine focus

Side by Side

Joan leads 10 of 14 categories

Feature
JoanJoanPick
SkeddaSkedda
Overall score★★★★★ 4.9/5★★★★☆ 4.3/5
Hardware displays✓ Purpose-built ePaper✗ None
Setup time<15 min per room1–2 hours
Visitor management✓ Full suite✗ Not available
Desk booking✓ Included✓ Included
Room booking✓ Included✓ Included
Analytics & reporting✓ Advanced~ Basic
Google Calendar sync✓ Yes✓ Yes
Outlook / M365 sync✓ Yes~ Issues reported
Slack / Teams integration✓ Yes~ Limited
AI booking assistant✓ In development✗ No
Free tier✓ Free trial✗ Removed in 2025
G2 rating⭐ 4.7/5⭐ 4.6/5
Best forAny office sizeComplex rule-based scheduling

Score: Joan 10 · Skedda 0 · Draw 4

See Joan →
The Details

Category by category — where each platform stands

1.

Hardware wins the hallway — Joan has it, Skedda doesn't

TL;DR: Joan ships ePaper room displays. Skedda has no hardware at all. For most offices, this is decisive.

This is where Joan has a clear advantage. Joan's purpose-built ePaper room displays are battery-powered, mount on any wall without cable runs, and show real-time availability to anyone walking past. Skedda has no hardware offering — you'd need to source, purchase, and configure a third-party tablet separately, which adds cost and complexity. Worth noting: Joan's hardware is an upfront investment, so for very small offices (under 5 rooms) with tight budgets, the value calculation shifts.

Winner:Joan
2.

Setup: 15 minutes vs a couple of hours

TL;DR: Both are DIY-friendly. Joan is faster out of the box; Skedda takes longer because its rules engine is deeper.

Joan takes under 15 minutes per room to set up — the displays are plug-and-play, and the admin panel is intuitive. Skedda is also manageable for basic use, but the depth of its booking rule customization means the setup process takes longer, particularly for complex office environments. Neither platform requires dedicated IT support.

Winner:Joan
3.

Booking rules: Skedda's clear strength

TL;DR: If your scheduling logic is genuinely complex, Skedda's rules engine is best in class.

This is Skedda's strongest suit — and it genuinely excels here. Skedda offers the most flexible booking rule configuration we've seen: minimum/maximum durations, buffer time between bookings, blackout periods, resource-specific rules, and approval workflows. Joan's booking rules cover the needs of most offices but don't match Skedda's granular depth. If your office has genuinely complex scheduling logic — think co-working spaces, universities, or shared facilities — Skedda is the more considered choice.

Winner:Skedda (this category only)
4.

Visitor management — included vs not offered

TL;DR: Joan has a full visitor suite built in. Skedda has none. If reception matters, this ends the comparison.

Joan includes a full visitor management suite — pre-registration, badge printing, host notifications, and visitor logs — integrated with the same platform used for room and desk booking. Skedda has no visitor management functionality. If front desk visitor experience is part of your requirements, this category alone can decide the shortlist.

Winner:Joan
5.

Analytics: real answers for facilities managers

TL;DR: Joan's dashboards are deeper. Skedda covers the basics but user-level breakdowns are limited.

Joan's analytics dashboard covers room utilisation rates, peak booking times, no-show rates, and desk occupancy — giving facilities managers actionable data. Skedda's analytics are functional but shallower: multiple reviewers on G2 note that "breaking down data by team or individual user is limited." For data-driven workplace decisions, Joan provides more insight out of the box.

Winner:Joan
6.

Integrations: Microsoft 365 sync

TL;DR: Both integrate with Google and Microsoft. Joan's M365 sync is more consistently reliable in reviews.

Both platforms integrate with Google Calendar and Microsoft 365. Skedda has received user reports of Outlook integration issues — a gap worth checking for Microsoft-heavy organisations. Joan's Microsoft 365 integration is consistently well-reviewed, with bidirectional calendar sync that works reliably in enterprise environments.

Winner:Joan
7.

Pricing: free tier and total cost of ownership

TL;DR: Skedda dropped its free tier in 2025. Joan still offers a free trial. Hardware is an upfront cost to weigh.

Skedda removed its free tier in 2025, which triggered SMB pricing complaints in reviews. Joan offers a free trial with no credit card required. Neither platform publishes flat pricing publicly — both use quote-based pricing at scale. Joan's hardware adds upfront cost, but total cost of ownership is comparable once you factor in the visitor management and analytics modules that would otherwise be separate line items.

Result:Draw — depends on office size and requirements
What Real Users Say

G2 ratings at a glance

Joan logoJoan

G2 · 4.7/5

"Setup was fast — we had all 12 rooms running in an afternoon."

— Verified G2 review

"Took a bit of time to figure out the admin panel initially, but once set up it's been seamless."

— Verified G2 review

"Visitor management and room booking in one platform — we cancelled two other tools."

— Verified G2 review
Skedda logoSkedda

G2 · 4.6/5

"The booking rules are genuinely powerful — exactly what our co-working space needed."

— Verified G2 review

"Great for complex scheduling, though the analytics could go deeper."

— Verified G2 review

"Outlook sync has been unreliable for us — we had to build a workaround."

— Verified G2 review

Who should choose each

Choose Joan if:

  • You want hardware displays outside meeting rooms
  • You need visitor management included
  • You're managing desk booking AND room booking
  • You want advanced analytics and utilisation reporting
  • You're a mid-market office (50–2,000 employees)
  • You want everything in one platform

Choose Skedda if:

  • You have complex, rule-based booking requirements
  • You manage a co-working space, university, or shared facility
  • You don't need hardware displays
  • You don't need visitor management
  • Booking rule flexibility is your #1 priority

Editor's note: if you don't clearly fall into Skedda's rule-engine niche, Joan is the safer all-round pick — it's the platform we'd deploy in our own office.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

For most offices, yes. Joan combines hardware room displays, room booking, desk booking, visitor management, and analytics in one unified platform. Skedda is better only in one specific scenario: offices with highly complex booking rules that don't require hardware or visitor management.

Editorial conclusion

After six weeks of testing, we'd choose Joan.

Skedda is a well-built product with a genuinely excellent rules engine. But most offices don't need a rules engine — they need room displays that just work, desk booking, a visitor sign-in flow, and analytics that answer real questions. Joan delivers all of that in one platform, backed by 8,000+ offices worldwide. If that's the office you're building, this decision isn't close.

See Joan's Room Booking Solution →

Free trial · No credit card · 15-min setup

Editorial recommendation based on independent testing. OfficeTechReview does not accept paid placements.

Was this review helpful?

Your feedback shapes what we test next.